**UPDATE April 2016** eduCanon is now called PlayPosit
In preparation for my summer tech training, I have been evaluating tools to create video lessons. These tools could be used to create flipped lessons where the students watch the video outside of class. These tools make the videos interactive and also allow teachers to see if students actually watched the video before class.
I have evaluated EDpuzzle, eduCanon and Zaption. I am using the free versions of each to evaluate all three tools. Two of these tools, Zaption and eduCanon, offer premium versions for a fee.
EDpuzzle is completely free for teachers--they do not offer a premium version. EDpuzzle allows you to create classes and track student progress through the videos. Students need an account for EDpuzzle but they do not need an email address to create an account. Students can add themselves to the classes you create using a class code.
With EDpuzzle you can upload your own videos or use videos from one of many sources like YouTube, Khan Academy, TED, Numberphile, TeacherTube and more. You can crop the video and use just the portions you like or you can use the entire video. EDpuzzle allows you to add questions to any point in the video. You can add multiple choice or open ended questions. You can also add comments to the video to better explain video contents. EDpuzzles can be assigned to students through the EDpuzzle interface or you can share a link or embed a puzzle on a blog or website. EDpuzzle allows you to search already created puzzles and edit them. Here is a sample EDpuzzle.
eduCanon allows you to create bulbs which include video and other elements. Video can come from YouTube (several educational YouTube channels are linked directly to from the eduCanon dashboard), Khan Academy, National Geographic, Shmoop and more. You can crop the video to get just the portion you want to include in the bulb or use the entire video. The free version allows you to add multiple choice and check all that apply questions. You can also add a reflective pause. The text editor allows you to add text as well as images, links and embed codes. You can even pause the video and record your own voice. The premium version gives you additional question options that include free response, fill in the blank, skip to a moment in the video and viewing websites along side the video. The free version allows you to create unlimited lessons, monitor unlimited students and create up to eight classes. Below is a sample eduCanon bulb.
Zaption allows you to create video tours. The free version of Zaption allows you to add text slides, image slides, drawing features (this could be good to have students work out a math problem), and open response, multiple choice and check box questions. You can trim a video to get just the portion you want. The free version allows you to add six interactive elements with a single video. You can also copy and edit Zaption tours that other teachers have created. The premium version gives access to additional tools including numerical response questions, drawn response questions, discussions and a replay feature. Below is a sample Zaption tour.
All three services allow you to embed the completed videos. Zaption does not require students to create an account to access tours. EDpuzzle does require an account for students but they do not need an email address to create an account and can log in via Google or Edmodo. eduCanon also allows students to log in with their Google or Edmodo accounts or they can create an account using only a username, no email address needed.
When assigning an EDpuzzle the teacher can select an option to prevent skipping. This means the student must go through the video in its entirety and cannot just skip ahead to the questions.
The eduCanon student sign up process could be confusing. In order to join a class students are presented with a box that says "Teacher class or name." On first glance it looks as if a student has to search by teacher name or class to join a class. On the teacher's profile there is a teacher search code. This code can be entered in the student's "Teacher class or name" search box. This is much easier than trying to search by name or class. But this feature is not explained well on the student side. Once in a class, students can see assignments. eduCanon videos do not allow the students to skip ahead. They must watch the video from beginning to end. The eduCanon videos do not show where the questions are located on the timeline until after the questions are answered. Once the questions are answered students can go back and review the questions by clicking the marker on the timeline.
All three services provide video analytics which allows the teacher to track student progress. Zaption gives you a break down of right and wrong answers as well as how long a student spent viewing a video. This is helpful since Zaption does not provide the teacher with the ability to prevent students from skipping ahead in the video. If a student watched a two minute video in thirty seconds and answered all the questions, you can be pretty sure they skipped ahead to the questions! Of the three services, Zaption provides the best analytics.
So I suppose the next logical question is, which one do I like best? There are pieces out of each service that I like. I really like the analytics Zaption provides. But I like the ability in EDpuzzle and eduCanon to prevent the students from skipping ahead in the videos. I worry that EDpuzzle is completely free with no premium version to support it. I think most teachers could get by with the free versions of Zaption or eduCanon although the premium version of Zaption does include some nice extras.
I think the key with these video lesson tools is like any other tech tool, find the one that works best for you and use it. There is no reason to use all three of these tools because they are so similar.